
Creamy Tomato Soup With Grilled Cheese Croutons on Top
Published: Jan 15, 2025
Creamy tomato soup topped with golden grilled cheese croutons — the classic pairing in one bowl, ready in 40 minutes.

Creamy tomato soup topped with golden grilled cheese croutons — the classic pairing in one bowl, ready in 40 minutes.
If you are looking for an ultra-satisfying, restaurant-quality meal that comes together with minimal effort, this Creamy Tomato Soup With Grilled Cheese Croutons on Top is about to become your new favorite. Everything is cooked to juicy, golden perfection with wholesome ingredients and incredible depth of flavor.
One simple tip!
Cook the tomato paste for a full minute before the tomatoes go in. Raw paste tastes tinny, and that sharpness survives the whole simmer if you skip this step.
Step-by-Step Photos



Why You’ll Love This Recipe
Ingredients Notes & Variations
Here is an overview of what you will need for this recipe. Be sure to scroll down to the printable recipe card below for exact scaled measurements!
olive oil
2 tbspyellow onion
1 piecediced
garlic
3 piececloves, minced
tomato paste
2 tbspcanned crushed tomatoes
28 ozone 28-ounce can
vegetable broth
3 cuplow sodium
dried basil
1 tspsugar
1 tspsalt
1 tspplus more to taste
black pepper
0.5 tspfreshly ground
heavy cream
0.5 cupbutter
2 tbspsoftened, for the grilled cheese
sourdough bread
4 pieceslices
cheddar cheese
1.5 cupshredded
fresh basil leaves
0.25 cuptorn, for serving
How to Make (Step-by-Step Overview)
Here is a quick summary of the preparation process. Detailed cooking temperatures and step timers are included in the recipe card below.
Our Pro Tips for Success
- •Cook the tomato paste for a full minute before the tomatoes go in. Raw paste tastes tinny, and that sharpness survives the whole simmer if you skip this step.
- •Blend for a full minute after the soup looks smooth. Bits of onion and tomato skin hide in the corners and show up later as grit.
- •Keep the heat low once the cream is in. A hard boil can split the cream and leave white flecks, so take the pot off the heat as soon as it is hot.
- •Cut the croutons only after the sandwiches have rested for a minute. Hot cheese slides out under the knife if you cut too soon.
- •Drop the croutons on top at the table, not in the kitchen. They stay crisp for a few minutes at most, and every minute in the soup softens them.
Storage & Make-Ahead Instructions
Our Recipe Precision Calculators
Calculate exact roasting times, internal temperatures, brining ratios, and safe thaw windows.
Creamy tomato soup with grilled cheese croutons takes the two halves of the classic lunch pairing and puts them in the same bowl. The soup is smooth and tomato-forward with a little cream to round the edges, and the croutons are cubes of buttery grilled cheese, crisp outside and melted inside, dropped on top right before serving. One spoonful gets you both.
The trick is timing. The soup can simmer as long as it likes, but the croutons go in at the very last second. Put them in early and they soak through and sink. Drop them on top when the bowls are already on the table and they stay crisp long enough to eat with a spoon.
Why This Tomato Soup Works
Good tomato soup starts with the tomatoes, and canned crushed tomatoes are the right call here. They are picked and packed at peak ripeness, so they taste more like a tomato in January than most fresh ones do. Crushed tomatoes also give the soup body without a long cook. Whole peeled tomatoes need more breaking down, and diced tomatoes can leave the soup chunky unless you blend it for a long time.
The soup cooks in one pot in about 25 minutes. Onion and garlic soften in olive oil first, then tomato paste goes in and cooks for a minute. That minute matters. Raw tomato paste tastes tinny and sharp. Cooked briefly in oil, it turns a darker red and tastes rounder and sweeter. You can see the change happen in the pan.
Vegetable broth thins the tomatoes to soup consistency. Three cups is the right amount for a soup that coats a spoon without being heavy. After a simmer, an immersion blender takes it smooth. If you only have a countertop blender, work in batches and leave the lid vented with a towel over the top, because hot soup expands and can blow the lid off.
Cream goes in last, off the boil. Stir it in over low heat and the soup turns a soft orange-red and tastes gentle instead of sharp. A pinch of sugar does the same job from a different direction. Tomatoes vary in acidity from can to can, and sugar is not there to make the soup sweet. It takes the edge off the acid so the tomato flavor reads clearly.
The Grilled Cheese Croutons
The croutons are a real grilled cheese sandwich, cooked first and cut into cubes after. That is what makes them different from plain toasted bread cubes. Each cube has a buttery crisp crust and a melted middle, so they eat like little sandwiches instead of dry croutons.
Sourdough is the best bread for this. It holds its shape when cut, and the slight tang works with the tomato soup. White sandwich bread also works but softens faster, so cut the cubes a little bigger and serve them even quicker. Cheddar melts well and gives the croutons a sharp flavor that stands up to the soup. A mild cheese disappears next to the tomatoes.
Butter the outside of the bread, not the pan. Butter on the bread browns evenly and gives you control over how much fat is on each slice. Cook over medium heat, not high. High heat burns the bread before the cheese melts, and you end up with a dark crust and a cold center. Medium heat takes about 3 minutes per side, and the cheese should be fully melted by the time the bread is golden.
Let the sandwich rest for a minute before cutting it. Hot cheese slides out under the knife if you cut too soon. A serrated knife works best on the crust. Cut the sandwich into cubes about an inch across. Smaller cubes sink. Bigger ones are hard to eat with a spoon.
Getting the Soup Smooth
The blender decides the texture. An immersion blender is the easiest tool for this job. Move it slowly through the pot and keep the head under the surface so it does not spray hot soup. Blend for a full minute after the soup looks smooth, because tiny bits of onion and tomato skin hide in the corners and show up later as grit.
If the soup still feels rough after blending, pass it through a fine mesh strainer. This is an extra step, but it is the difference between a good soup and a silky one. Press the soup through with a ladle and discard what is left in the strainer. You will lose a little volume, so taste and add a splash more broth if it feels too thick.
Thickness is a matter of taste. Some people like a soup that coats the spoon and holds the croutons up. Others like it thinner so it drinks like a broth. Start with the recipe amounts, then adjust. Add broth a quarter cup at a time to thin it. To thicken, simmer it uncovered for 5 more minutes and let some water cook off.
What to Serve With It
The soup is a full lunch on its own, because the croutons bring bread and cheese to the bowl. If you want more on the table, a simple green salad with a sharp vinaigrette is the best partner. The acid in the dressing cuts through the cream in the soup and keeps the meal from feeling heavy.
A second sandwich on the side is too much. The croutons already give you the grilled cheese flavor, and a whole sandwich next to the bowl turns lunch into a project. If you are feeding hungry teenagers, add a side of roasted potatoes or a few apple slices instead. Both sit well next to tomato soup without competing with it.
Seasoning and Adjusting the Flavor
Taste the soup twice. Taste once after blending, before the cream goes in, and adjust the salt. Taste again after the cream, because cream softens salt and you may need another pinch. Canned tomatoes vary a lot in salt, so the amount in the recipe is a starting point, not a rule.
If the soup tastes flat, it usually needs salt, not more ingredients. Add a pinch, stir, and wait 30 seconds before tasting again. Salt takes a moment to dissolve and register. If the soup tastes too acidic, add the sugar a half teaspoon at a time. If it tastes too sweet, a splash of lemon juice or a little more salt will pull it back.
Dried basil goes in with the broth so it has time to soften and release flavor. Fresh basil is a garnish, not a cooking ingredient here. Torn leaves on top add color and a fresh smell that dried basil cannot give. If you only have fresh basil, add a handful of leaves to the blender with the soup and skip the dried basil entirely.
Common Mistakes
The most common mistake is boiling the soup after the cream is in. Cream can split at a hard boil, leaving little white flecks and a grainy texture. Keep the heat low once the cream is added and take the pot off the heat as soon as it is hot. If the cream does split, blending the soup again will usually bring it back together.
The second mistake is cooking the grilled cheese too fast. High heat browns the bread in a minute, but the cheese in the middle stays solid. You want a steady medium heat and patience. Press the sandwich gently with a spatula once, when you flip it, to help the cheese make contact. Pressing more than that squeezes the melted cheese out the sides.
The third mistake is making the croutons too early. A grilled cheese sandwich cut into cubes cools fast and loses its crisp edge in about 10 minutes. Cook the sandwiches while the soup is in its last few minutes of simmering, so the croutons are hot and crisp when the bowls go out.
How Long It Keeps
The soup keeps well. The croutons do not. Store them separately and treat them as two different foods with two different timelines. The soup actually tastes better the next day, once the flavors have had a night to settle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, up to 4 days ahead in the fridge. The soup tastes even better the next day, but make the grilled cheese croutons fresh each time, because they go soft within minutes of sitting.
Drop them on top of the soup at the table, right before eating, and cut them about an inch across. Smaller cubes sink and soak through fast, while bigger cubes hold their crisp edge longer.
Creamy Tomato Soup With Grilled Cheese Croutons on Top
Creamy tomato soup topped with golden grilled cheese croutons — the classic pairing in one bowl, ready in 40 minutes.
Ingredients
Click to check offInstructions
Step-by-StepThe Cooking With Guru Team
Our recipes are developed and checked by the Cooking With Guru team. Nutrition figures are estimates calculated from USDA data, and yields scale with the built-in portion tools so the recipe fits your kitchen.
More lunch recipes to try!
Comments & Questions (0)
Join the conversationNo comments yet!
Be the first to leave a comment or ask a question about Creamy Tomato Soup With Grilled Cheese Croutons on Top.
You May Also Like

Creamy Tuscan White Bean Skillet with Crispy Sage

One-Pot Chicken Pot Pie Soup

Creamy Chicken Gnocchi Soup (Better Than the Restaurant Version)

Turmeric Lentil Soup with Coconut

Instant Pot Butternut Squash and Apple Soup

Mushroom Bolognese Rigatoni

One-Pot Sausage, Kale and White Bean Stew
